Siwatibau: A role model (2003)

[Fiji Times, 16 Aug. 2003]

In the eighties, whenever Siwatibau began to speak, some in the audience (typically civil servants, corporate types, and academia) would inwardly chuckle or even groan. For they had heard the message many a time before, and some could repeat it, imitating Siwa’s slow drawl: “If you want economic development…. first the economy must grow…. for that you need macroeconomic stability ….. and so you must have fiscal prudence… but we all know, money doesn’t grow on trees, and so…..”. Siwa would go on, one slow logical step after another. Often.

In the last few years of his illustrious life, especially after he left the institutional constraints of being head of a UN organization in Vanuatu, ESCAP, many in the Pacific would chuckle (and some grumble) that Siwa

was singing the same song over and over again: the need for good governance, honesty, integrity, transparency, accountability, dedication, and hard work. Sometimes, the uncomfortable messages were not wellreceived. ButthehorriblecollapseofeconomiesinAfrica,CaribbeanandthePacific,havedrivenhome that the issues Siwa talked about were vital for economic development and the improvement in the lives of our ordinary people.

Siwa made no bones that powerful unprincipled human beings and their actions were the causes of many of these economic failures, their wasteful expenditures, their unsustainable public debts, and the resulting impoverishment of the people.

At his church service in Christchurch

At the church service in Christchurch, Tania Siwatibau chose a very appropriate Bible reading (Proverbs 14: 29-34) for her father, who often echoed the sentiments in three lines out of Tania’s reading:

“If you oppress poor people, you insult the God who made them; but kindness shown to the poor is an act of worship…. Wicked people bring about their own downfall by their evil deeds, but good people are protected by their integrity…. Righteousness makes a nation great; sin is a disgrace to any nation”.

I doubt if there are totally good people or totally evil people in this world. But those of us who have known Siwa (and his wife Suliana), know that they have tried to live the good values, and inculcate them in their children, throughout their lives- in their work place, in society with their friends and relatives, and in their own home.

Indeed, there can be no better role model for the professional civil servant or bureaucrat than Siwa.

What a role model for the Pacific

In every one of our Pacific countries, government ministers, permanent secretaries, chief executives of the numerous public enterprises, officials of reserve banks, and even senior managers in all our numerous organizations, can get rich quick, through their day to day decisions, legal or otherwise:

  • fishing or logging licenses;
  • monopoly rights;
  • special tax exemptions;
  • import licenses or quotas;
  • tariff protection;
  • pressure on financial institutions to give loans to chosen clients;
  • visa or passport approvals;
  • classifying an import under a lower tax rate;
  • ignoring things going wrong

Unethical decisions allow some people to make money at tax-payers’ expense. Some people, are only too happy to pay a bribe to the bureaucrat to expedite the deal, as they do everywhere in the world, and the Pacific. Siwatibau, throughout his long public service career, has often been in powerful positions where he could have easily got rich through unethical means. He has been Director of Planning and Development, Permanent Secretary of Finance, Governor of the Reserve Bank, and Vice Chancellor of the University of the South Pacific. Yet during all those years, there has never ever been a hint of corruption or unfair and unethical dealing, associated with him.

Siwa is universally known to have been a hard-working, totally honest, and infinitely dedicated civil servant, whetherinnormaltimesortimesofstrifeandturmoil. A person to be totally trusted with public resources, given by tax-payers or donor countries. He often preached to civil servants in influential positions I have listed above not to fall in to personal greed. Read Siwatibau: a Voice of Reason. A collection of writings by Siwatibau, edited by Wadan Narsey (2010).

During the coups

During the political turmoil of the 1987 coups, while he was still the Governor of the Reserve Bank of Fiji, he became the key administrator governing Fiji. Siwa was totally opposed to the illegal military coups in 1987. For Siwa, no “cause” justified the illegal “means” which people had chosen to use. Siwa resigned from his

Governorship of the Reserve Bank, and went on to serve the region through his headship of the ESCAP office in Vanuatu.

During the 2000 coups, some coup leaders proposed Siwa’s name as an Interim Prime Minister. While gently refusing, Siwa was astonished that those who were blatantly breaking the laws of the country, would think that he would come back to Fiji to tacitly support their illegal actions, which were to cause ordinary Fiji people so much grief. It is no secret to friends and colleagues that Siwatibau was disappointed at the current lack of progress in political reconciliation in Fiji, at the continuous aggression, personal attacks and counter-attacks, and just plain nastiness in the political arena.

His art of gentle criticism

I well remember Siwa’s gentle and sympathetic advice some twenty years ago when Indo-Fijian staff at USP had encountered systematic racial attacks and had publicly and bitterly retaliated: “Wadan, you can always disagree with others’ views, but always leave room for them to respect themselves. If you don’t, they can only become nasty”. Perhaps if we and some of our politicians heeded Siwa’s advice, politics in Fiji would be more peaceful and constructive, rather than the divisive force it currently is.

His advocacy of good governance

Siwa was extremely keen to ensure that there was a part of the University which specifically focused on issues regarding good governance in the region. Siwa, despite being burdened with numerous responsibilities, felt strongly enough about creating a peaceful political climate in Fiji, to take on the chairmanship of the National Reconciliation Committee, to see if he could make a difference there.

As he tried to make a difference in all the many walks of his complex life, not the least was his attempt to reconcile the conflicting pulls of his traditional Fijian culture and mataqali, with that of living a just and good life in a multi-cultural Fiji, and doing well by his family.
Even in death, his continuing concern for his people

Many in Fiji would have been puzzled by Siwa’s request that he be buried in Christchurch and not in Fiji. This was not a typically “Fijian” request by someone who was undoubtedly one of Fiji’s foremost sons, Fijian or otherwise. Suliana Siwatibau gently explained to the University delegation to Christchurch, that Siwa deeply appreciated the sense of community that had been extended to him in Christchurch- by all kinds of ordinary people who volunteered their services to help those with cancer. Suli spoke of Siwa’s great appreciation of the incredible beauty of Christchurch in spring. Indeed Christchurch is a garden city, with virtually every household garden having flowering shrubs, creepers, trees, with gorgeous colours bursting, flowing, and cascading, overpowering the senses. Sights not to be seen in Fiji.

But Siwa had a multi-racial mataqali in Fiji as well

But none of us doubt the outpouring of love, affection, and kindness that Siwa’s grand community in Fiji would have showered upon him at his time of sickness and death: his relatives and mataqali in Natewa, Cakaudrove, throughout Fiji; his traditional Fijian linkages; his school friends and work colleagues, the political and social leaders of Fiji of all races and religions; the business leaders who respected him not for any special favors (which he didn’t do them), but for his great honesty and integrity. And beautiful flowers would not have been lacking either.

But Siwa also understood that a traditional Fijian funeral for him could have also become a real financial burden on his people, which he wanted to avoid. It is not for non-Fijians to comment on Siwa’s wishes in thisregard. Therearesocialplusesaswellasminusestoanyculturaltradition,evenifitimposesmaterial costs on the people. It is an interesting issue that many progressive Fijians are rethinking.

Suffice to say that Siwa’s family respected his wish that he be buried in Christchurch, and that his relatives and kin groups not engage in the normal Fijian funeral practices which could have imposed heavy financial burdens. Siwa’sfamilyandimmediatechiefs,hardasitwasforthem,conveyedhiswishestomanytraditional Fijian chiefs and leaders who wanted to pay tribute to Siwa, even in Christchurch. Siwa’s family even heeded

Siwa’s request that there be no floral tributes at his funeral, and that they could donate to a cancer fund for Fiji, if mourners wished.

We can still show our respect in Fiji

Well, Fijians and Fiji can respect Siwa’s wish that there be no wastage of resources on his death. Fijians and Fiji can still gather to celebrate the values he believed in, and lived out, in his everyday life. For Siwa, as Chairman of the National Reconciliation Committee, would not have objected to an inter-faith memorial service in Fiji that brought together people of different races, cultures, religions, and political persuasions. To celebrate multi-culturalism, multi-racialism, honesty, integrity, accountability, hard work and dedication to one’scountry. Therewillnodoubtbepeoplefromothercountriesintheregionwhowouldlovetojoinin.

An icon for our people

While the humble Siwa might have objected to anything being named after him, the University might well find any number of donors willing to provide funds to expedite a “Siwatibau Lecture Series” on issues of critical development importance, given by eminent academics, perhaps at suitably named “Siwatibau Lecture Theaters”, around the USP region. Why not establish a special “Siwatibau Award” annually made to a top public servant (in Government or public enterprise), who embodies the values that Siwa stood for.

For let us remember that in small Pacific countries, it can be extremely difficult for a bureaucrat to resist untoward pressure from Ministers, chiefs, powerful businessmen, or even family members. There are many bureaucrats around the region who are performing in the Siwatibau mold and to whom credit should be given, so that Siwatibau can continue to be a role model.

In today’s Fiji, how many icons- “perfect people”- can we hold up as role models for our children? While it is common for funeral orations to go overboard with the flattery of the departed person, Jone Dakuvula’s multi-faceted appreciation of Siwa’s life at the Christchurch service, had no hint of exaggeration in the many accoladesreceivedfromsomanyquarters. Indeed,manyofuschuckledwhenthepresidingpriestaskedfor forgiveness from those that Siwa had might have sinned against.

Of course, no one really knows what personal demons or vices any of our “perfect people” grapple with, in the deep dark depths of the night. “Perfect people” can also be real pains. But for those of us who imbibe too much, gallivant too much, or have other vices which our children are all too aware of, it is useful to have an icon like Savenaca Siwatibau.

 

Amelia Rokotuivuna: a pioneer feminist (2005)

[Born 1941. Passed on 2005.]. [The Fiji Times and Fiji Sun, 7 June 2005]

It is not easy, in a small society, to hold views that are different from your social group, especially when you are aheadofyourtime. ItisnoteasytobeaFijiansocialist,feminist,multiracialradicalinasocietydrivenbyour

potent mixture of patriarchal communalism and capitalism. It is not easy to be honest with friends and foe alike, regardless of rank, status, wealth and power. Amelia Vakasokolaca Rokotuivuna did all that, and more.

Born in the village of Vatukarasa (Tailevu) in 1941, Amelia lived her early years under the harsh conditions of the Vatukoula gold mines, where her father was a cook. Yet she rose to being the Head Girl of Adi Cakobau School, the premier and elitist Fijian school for girls. At work, she took on the charismatic leadership of the Young Woman’s Christian Association (YWCA).

Till the end, she also remained the fun-loving warm human being, who passionately loved rugby, good wine, music and food, and the company of old friends.

The YWCA

Amelia was the first Fiji staff member of the Fiji YWCA founded in 1962. She was mentored by Anne Walker and Ruth Lechte of World YWCA , and Amelia became the first Fijian Executive Director in 1972.

The “Y” was an active progressive association for women’s rights, Fiji’s independence, anti-nuclear protests, and multiracialism in Fiji. The YWCA was known for its traditional roles in the vocational training of women. But under Amelia, the YWCA also became a leader in the struggle for women’s rights, workers’ and union rights, and economic and political justice for all.

Amelia and the YWCA were one of the catalysts in the formation of ATOM (Against Testing on Murorua), FANG (Fiji Anti-Nuclear Group), and NFIP (Nuclear Free and Independent Pacific) which eventually became PCRC (Pacific Concerns Resource Centre). Amelia was a leading advocate for the independence movements in the Pacific.

Amelia was a focal point

At the Y, Amelia helped bring together many like-minded people of all races. As a USP mathematics lecturer in 1973, I was pulled into a critical study of Fiji’s newly independent economy, being conducted by Amelia and the USP Student Christian Movement. Fiji: A developing Australian Colony was Fiji’s first radical publication, published with the authors suitably recorded as Rokotuivuna et al, but attracting the ire of Fiji’s political leaders and the elite.

Surprising for an Indo-Fijian non-Christian male, I found myself on the YWCA committees on economic justice or inflation, part of a YWCA team making submissions to the Street Commission for constitutional reform, marching with the anti-nuclear movement, and numerous other YWCA activities. Perhaps an added attraction for my attachment to the YWCA may have been Amelia’s Deputy Director at the time (Joan Yee), later to become my wife.

But the mathematician soon converted to being a life-long economist, sharing much in common with the social and political vision of Amelia and her friends. Many others from USP and outside of the YWCA, were also drawn to the wide ranging activities of the YWCA, whether it be political education campaigns or modern dance. Many of Amelia’s friends from that time continue to be active today.

Amelia the uncompromising

Amelia, as the Executive Director of the YWCA in Fiji, came into contact with all kinds of powerful people: Prime Ministers and politicians, millionaire businessmen, corporate types, communal leaders and university professors. She interacted with all with uncompromising honesty, regardless of their wealth, power, status or qualification.

Amelia was a Fijian commoner who expected the highest of standards from her chiefs. She was a committed socialist who participated in labor movements, but refused to blindly follow leaders who fell short of her democratic and co-operative ideals.

She was a pioneer feminist who was dismayed by the populist “Gucci feminists” she saw in later years, but buoyed by the large numbers of young women taking on leadership roles. Ameia was a profound influence on many of the younger feminist friends- Dr Claire Slatter, Dr Vanessa Griffen, Dr Arlene Griffin, Dr Atu Bain, Dr Makereta Waqavonovono, Dr Margaret Chung, Joan Yee (once her Deputy at the WYCA), and many others too many to mention.

Amelia loved her friends, but left them with no illusions if she disapproved of their behavior or views. Amelia was vehemently opposed to the ill-effects of free trade and globalization. Economist friends had to tread carefully when pointing out the many benefits of globalization for the poor of the developing world, including the NGOs.

page6image3235048864

Amelia was the head of an NGO that benefited from donations from the business community, but refused to compromise on her opposition to employers who refused to give a fair deal to workers.
Rising to the Fijian challenges
It has been illuminating and humbling to see how Amelia as a fiercely proud Fijian, rose to the challenges of being a good citizen in a multi-racial Fiji. While non-Fijians have had a tough time in post-coups Fiji, their issues and perspectives are fairly clearly defined. But most educated indigenous Fijians are facing profoundly difficult choices between their communal traditions and obligations, and the pitiless modern demands to be materially successful and compete with “others” in a globalized world order, while following rules set by international democratic ideals and market capitalism.

With the traditional leadership severely weakened, the ordinary common Fijians face the mammoth task of having to redefine their own personal roles and responsibilities vis a vis their immediate families, their mataqali, other communities, and the world.

For more than three decades, Amelia’s response to the critical challenges (such as the coups of 1987 and 2000) has been more radical than that of most Fijians. In her personal life, she has been an honest citizen respecting the rights of all races, classes and genders in Fiji. But she has also taken a strong leadership role over the years, advocated the same ideals for Fijians and the wider Fiji community.

She has naturally also paid a personal price – at times, facing alienation with some leaders, some friends, and even some family members. She has faced the occasional ostracism with stoicism and good humor.

Her purity of purpose has often been vindicated years later, with friendships being renewed as Amelia’s views were grudgingly recognized to be correct, or views which people respected, even if they agreed to disagree. Remarkably, Amelia would maintain cordial social relations even with political leaders and persons whose views were poles apart from her – a trait we would like to see more in our leaders.
Amelia the bohemian
It never ceased to amaze me how Amelia cared so little for personal accumulation and wealth. At one stage, Amelia worked for international organizations like the World YWCA with their relatively high salaries, in exotic locations such as Geneva. But she chose to come back to Fiji’s low salaries, for the more meaningful life and challenges amongst her own people.

Not that she was frugal. She could also cheerfully blow a large sum of money on a single meal with friends, whether at the Blue Boar in London or Biddy’s Steakhouse in Suva. She loved and looked after the children of relatives. Like many other Fijian leaders of her generation, she ended her life with no property in her own name.

Not goody two shoes

Amelia was not the typical “goody two shoes” whose company is painful for normal prim and proper persons. Amelia was a boisterous argumentative political wit who could out-talk most persons. She loved her red wine and she and some of her women friends could drink seasoned male friends under the table. Their loud ribald joking was not for Sunday School children.

Amelia loved nothing better than to be next to tuneful guitars strummed by her numerous musician friends, men and women. Friends will remember for a long time, the joyful image of Amelia surrounded by her ACS Old Girls crowd, belting out one classic Fijian song after another, and the melodious songs of the sixties and seventies.

Dying but not the end

More than a year ago, Amelia was diagnosed with cancer. Supported by her numerous friends in Fiji and abroad, she went through her operations and subsequent treatments with courage. She continued her joyous life. ThecancerreturnedandAmeliafaceduptoherimpendingendwithgoodhumor.Shewaspatientwith the never ending stream of friends. Last week her earthly flame was finally extinguished.

As was her wish and radical to the end, I was honored to assist in the cremation of Amelia at the Vatuwaqa Crematorium, but with the ceremony presided over by a Methodist priest saying the usual Christian prayers. Amelia’s nephew Peceli Rokotuivuna and numerous friends all took part in the sacred lighting of the funeral pyre. Her friends stayed on till the next morning to collect her ashes which were later scattered in her family river, one of the tributaries to the Rewa River, by Peceli and friends.

It was a privilege to have known Amelia for the last thirty years. There are many subtle ways in which we are all changed by the company of charismatic persons. Amelia was one such person who changed people for the good.

May Amelia’s visionary light shine on.

 

Dr. Ropate Qalo: a free spirit (2016)

[The Fiji Times, 9 April 2016]

Dear Salote, Sivo, Emele, Tui , the relatives and friends of Ropate. Thank you for the honor of asking me to deliver the eulogy, and I come from Melbourne despite my being “a person of interest” to the Fiji CID.

It is so pleasing to see so many of Ropate’s old friends here this morning, to pay tribute to one of our remarkable sons of Fiji. Nothing I say today will surprise you the family members or old friends, who have at some time or other, all enjoyed the company of Ropate. I have been privileged to have had the company, the comradeship and friendship of Ropate Qalo from 1973 when I first met at him at USP through our mutual friend and his Natewa kin Jone Dakuvula.

Ropate was an energetic Fijian intellectual, following in the footsteps of great Fijian academics like Rusiate Nayacakalau, deeply challenging the orthodox views on Fijian development. Ropate had a great big heart, great love of sports, a love of music, a love of academic life in theory and, unusual for academics, theory put into practice. He was a free man, subservient to none.

His genuine independence did not endear him to people in power, at the university where he worked for decades, or the wider body politics in Fiji. This showed in the trajectories that Ropate proudly followed throughout his life, with great personal dignity, self-respect and the respect of all who knew him, right to the end. But it was a dignity that shone because of his great warm heart, bursting with energy and music, with his home being open house to all his family and friends.

But as Salote, Emele, Tui and other relatives will readily admit, Ropate was also a very complicated person, indeed a very stubborn and difficult person at times. He rarely listened to advice, even when offered by his loving family members for his own good, as over his lack of attention to his diabetes and health. Had Ropate listened more to his family, we would not be gathered here so sadly today.

I will speak only about aspects of his life which the public may not be aware of, especially with the passage of time and the emigration of virtually ninety percent of many of our former academic colleagues from the 1970s and 1980s. Last year, I was very privileged and lucky enough to be able record some amateur music videos of Ropate and his friends, a small selection of which have been played here, which really illustrate better than words, what kind of person Ropate was.

Our love of fishing

More than forty years ago, Ropate and I indulged ourselves in our common love of fishing. Of course, we did the usual rounds around Nukulau and the Sandbank Passage. But with his close Bauan connections from his mother’s side, he and his uncle took me fishing in the protected Bau chiefly fishing grounds. Precisely lining up distant beacons, we would be hauling them in, at the drop of the lines. If the desired kawakawa were not biting, and even if the sabutu and kawago were still being hauled in, Ropate would pull anchor and move.

It was heavenly to be gliding back to Bau under sail, the starlight just giving way to dawn, with a full Esky. Most of the catch would be left in Bau, while the remainder would go fresh into the frying pans in my USP bachelor quarters, washed down with the usual amber liquid. Soon, Ropate was accommodating other keen fishing friends Vijay Naidu and Rajesh Chandra, until Ropate was gently reminded by his seniors on Bau, that we were outliving our welcome in the chiefly fishing waters, no doubt an early fish conservation measure.

A decade later, in UK the early eighties, Ropate and Salote came down all the way from Birmingham University to be at the Brighton Registry Office, where I caught the biggest fish of my life, a grand-daughter of Yee Man Sue, a shop-keeper from Korovou. Joan and I were blessed at our simple registry office ceremony by other friends from Fiji, Vijay Naidu and Shamima Ali, and Navi and Barbara Naisoro.

In the seventies and eighties, Joan and I were sharing Ropate’s rich family life in Nepani and Bagasau (Toorak). Ropate and Salote shared my parents’ Toorak home once upon his return from ANU when he had noreadyaccommodation. I won’t forget the lesson he taught this economist that production of the usual light Gujarati rotis, cannot be roughly estimated at 3 per person, when you have a big six foot national rugby winger to feed.

The sportsman

Ropate was a keen sportsman, and despite his size, was an extremely fleet-footed winger on the famous rugby Fiji First Fifteen that played the Lions at Buckhurst Park. He was not averse to challenging another rugby winger for a minor Marist rugby team to a 100 meter sprint, and used to be quite peeved when he did not always get his nose in front.

But Ropate was fantastic to have on our USP Staff soccer team, his size and speed no small asset when playing and beating many senior Suva teams.

A singer and musician

In the early years at USP, our staff XMas parties were not at Holiday Inn or other snotty expensive places, but in one of the larger lecture rooms at the bottom of the FBE building, with BYO huge pots of goat curry and kegsofbeer. The few oldies who remain will remember that the derelict nature of the surroundings were more than made up by the fantastic happy spirit of all the SSED (now FBE) staff, academics, typists (remember that occupation) and cleaners alike, something a bit strange, I suspect, for the USP “staff parties” of today, where the old community spirit seems missing. Ropate with his guitar and singing, would help keep those parties going until the early hours of the morning.

Sometimes, Joan and I and our young kids, would end up at the Tailevu farm with Ropate and his uncle Sam Marriot, while a Jesse Mucunabitu, long before he became famous, would sing along with us until the break of dawn.

At USP, Ropate fought for the underdog

Looking at the USP management today, no one would think that local regional academics once had to struggle to be trained and promoted or appointed to the highest positions. With expatriate cliques running the show, regional academics like Ropate and us, often faced a Catch 22 situation. We could not be promoted because we did not have PhDs, we could not easily get scholarships for training, and if we did, we would not be promoted until we finished our PhDs, which often took much longer than three years. If you did not finish in “reasonable time” you could be terminated. Others who never bothered with higher qualifications had little difficulty rising.

While it would have been so easy for Ropate, as an indigenous Fijian academic to receive favorable treatment,Ropatethrewinhislotwiththeunderdogs. Hewasoneofthe“GangofFour”,includingYadhu Nand Singh, Rajesh Chandra and yours truly, who defied the establishment, and eventually won our rights to be sent for our PhDs.

Some, like Ropate, naturally paid the price for taking on the management, with promotions refused for years. But the young regionals did prevail in the battles for regionalization, although it today seems a pyrrhic victory, young regionals again being bypassed by new expatriates, with the blessing of a regional VC who has forgotten his roots.

Ropate, social capital and iTaukei businesses

Ropate was one of the few Fijian academics who obtained a PhD from Australian National University. His pet academic hobby horse was the importance of “social capital” in economic development. Ropate believed that decision-makers in Fiji were far too focused on the economistic material concept of capital and capital accumulation, ignoring the far more important good social relations that ought to be at the center of all our development strategies. Ropate believed that our planners, and most of Fiji’s political, social and even religious leaders espoused material values in practice, even if they preached otherwise.

Rusiate Nayacakalou is well known for advising Fijian people that it was a monstrous lie for Fijian leaders to preach to their people that they could have both capitalist development and still cling to their traditional ways. But Ropate thought that there was a middle path where Fijians could enjoy capitalist development while preserving their communal strengths.

Of course, a major weakness of free market capitalism is that high rates of economic growth usually occur without a fair distribution of benefits, with the workers and weakest people being largely left behind, and income distribution often worsening. Ropate believed that family run Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) and cooperatives should be the desirable engine of growth for Fiji, rather than large corporations. SMEs and cooperatives ensure that the benefits were immediately enjoyed by the poorest members.

While we all know of the historical problems of co-operatives in Fiji and the failure of central planning in former socialist or communist countries, Ropate pointed out the great capitalist successes of union cooperatives such as Fijian Teachers Association, Fiji Teachers Union and FPSA Credit Unions. What distinguished Ropate from other USP academics who espoused similar views, was that he put his ideas into practice, by fostering his family concern, the Mucunabitu Iron Works. His ideas may be read in his book “Small Business: a study of a Fijian Family. The Mucunabitu Iron Works Contractor Cooperative Society Limited”. You can read my two page review of that book in The Daily Post, 4 April 1998. “Balancing tradition in a capitalist market economy”. A book review of MIW, Fijians in business by Dr. Ropate Qalo” is in my Volume 1 The Challenges of Growing the Fiji Economy (Reading 29). The MIW, powered along by Ropate’s energetic uncle Sam and his small dedicated group of workers, made many steel structures around Suva, as well as two at my own home in Raisara.

We all know that the greatest economic challenge facing Fiji for decades has been to ensure that indigenous Fijians occupy all the levels of the Fiji economy, and not just be the one leg providing land for the three legged stool. Ropate was well aware of the many Fijian businesses which received huge preferential funding, such as through the National Bank of Fiji or the EIMCOL schemes, with the enterprises collapsing under the weight of non-commercial demands made by family members, the mataqali for marriages or reguregu, or the numerous church talatala.

Ropate knew only too well that no Indo-Fijian or Gujarati or European or Chinese entrepreneur would make such extreme material sacrifices to sustain their social capital, but indigenous Fijians did, and many still do today. In his book, Ropate fostered the critical importance of Fijian owners of businesses to completely separate out the accumulation and re-investment needs of their businesses, from the resources that they freely chose to allocate for their traditional social obligations.

The tragedy, however, is that MIW stopped operating last year, not because of the burden of traditional demands, but because some large corporations obtained quality work from MIW after paying a small deposit, and then dragged their feet on the final payments, with some very big names not paying at all. The need to protect small business operators from our predatory large corporate sharks is rarely talked about at the

frequent talkfests on SMEs. Young researchers could write a nice project paper by just talking to Salote and Ropate’s uncle Sam about their bad debt-collecting experiences with large corporations.

Ropate the social person

Ropate Qalo was a social trail-blazer for indigenous Fijians, following in the footsteps of YWCA activist Amelia Rokotuivuna and the distinguished former USP Vice Chancellor and Governor of the Reserve Bank, the late Savenaca Siwatibau. Ropate, like Amelia, wanted to be cremated, somewhat disturbing to Christians who want the traditional burial. But more importantly, Ropate, like Siwatibau, also asked his family and mataqali not to have any reguregu or floral tributes, so that they would not be unduly burdened.

But even this hard-boiled Gujarati economist knows what sociologists and good social leaders all know. – that funerals, births, marriages and church services, are also occasions when family, mataqali, friends and communities, strengthen theircommonhumanity,culturalidentity, senseofpurposeandvaluesinlife,bygettingtogether,talking,eating,drinking,and singing, all requiring the sharing of resources. I am sure that Ropate’s family and mataqali must have been in a terrible quandary these last few days, trying to respect Ropate’s wish that there be no reguregu or floral tributes.

Just as he was in life, so also in death, Ropate continues to be a difficult person for his family, mataqali and friends to deal with.

Ropate’s difficult trajectory in life

It is a fact of life at USP (as elsewhere in Fiji), that any reasonably articulate indigenous Fijian, of chiefly connections, and especially with a PhD, will rapidly ascend in public or corporate life, sit on boards and enjoy all the perks that come with such positions, often enjoying the patronage of some corporate or political leader. But right from the earliest days of the governments of Ratu Mara and all others that have followed to the present day, Ropate chose not to seek these high positions nor to seek the patronage of any powerful political or corporate persons. Neither has he ever been tainted by any financial scandal either, in a country where the NBF disaster left many persons ruing their involvement in “get rich quick” schemes.

At USP, those who have been close to him over the years, know that Ropate felt that he was not given a fair go by those in decision-making, sometimes with alternative appointments being total disasters. Some twenty years ago, I myself was once part of a Screening Committee for a job which Ropate had applied. The Screening Committee (including myself) put too much weight on what appeared on CVs and another applicant (extremely senior in the Fiji Civil Service) was appointed. He later proved to be totally unsuitable and more interested in the part-time business he was running outside. I could not face Ropate for several years (and he did not talk to me), until he eventually forgave me for my personal blunder in judgement.

Recently, Ropate was deeply hurt when a 65 year retirement “rule” was applied to him at USP, while many others close to USP management and some expatriates, have been retained, well past the age of 70. Many of us thought that Ropate, with his passion for teaching, had so much to contribute to young Fijian academics: as a mentor, as a thinker of contentious ideas, a writer, and a willing communicator with the ordinary public, which few of our academics bother with.

But he kept contributing

As a committed academic, Ropate did not stop thinking and working at the age of 65. It is a great measure of Ropate’s dedication to learning and teaching, that he continued his community education work, by writing columns for The Fiji Times, followed by many readers. The Fiji Government Statistician, Epeli Waqavonovono, often enthused to me how glad he was that Ropate was writing and articulating issues for indigenous Fijians.

Ropate of course had his own unique writing style because he was never too direct in comments or criticism. Ropate would delicately go around, above, and below his central messages, his style puzzling to non-Fijians, but very clearly understood by other indigenous Fijians, who knew exactly what subtle points were being made, without being explicitly stated.

As one very senior Fijian chief once reminded me in Parliament, “you know Wadan, for us Fijians, how you state the facts is just as important as the facts you state so clearly”. Fijian politics is far more sophisticated than those of other ethnic groups, who usually behave, as is evident from our parliament, like bulls in a China shop. Mind you, Ropate could be quite bullish with his close friends, just as he was on the rugby field once upon a time.

Even after suffering a severe setback with the amputation of a foot, Ropate devoted his energy to encouraging his MIW cooperative workers to venture into farming on their Tailevu mataqali land, and to diversify from their steel construction work. Ropate and Salote showed great willingness and humility in supplementing their considerable Fijian knowledge of farming with ideas from skilled modern farmers like Yee Wah Sing.

In the last few months of his life, Ropate would sometimes announce, to the great annoyance of family and friends, that he had achieved all he wanted to in life, and was ready for the next stage. But that was just his few disappointments talking. Because Ropate kept learning, kept trying new ventures, kept singing, kept calling friends to his open home where he shared many a beer and kava (in that order), kept writing, and kept debating ideas with his intellectual friends. He really put into practice the great philosophical principle, that lifelikelove,isintheliving, thestriving,andthejourney,andnottobejudgedbyachievementsweallenjoy, or failures that we all find hurtful.

Ropate and even his family may not have seen his own life in full perspective, because he was far too immersed in it and his family also were too close to him, hobbled by familiarity. But Ropate came from a poor background, lived a materially poor life, did not accumulate any great wealth, or achieve any great status with the powerful in the land, yet accumulated massive amounts of social capital, that money cannot buy.

This multifaceted and complicated man, whatever difficulties he may have occasionally created, has been a bundle of energy and great joy throughout his life, for his family, mataqali, friends, and even strangers who came in contact with him.

Salote, Emele, Tui, and all of Ropate’s mataqali, I bear witness on behalf of all our friends who have known him for four decades and more, that it was a rare privilege and a joy to have been in the company of Dr. Ropate Rakuita Qalo and he will be sorely missed. The few videos of Ropate you have seen today, convey these sentiments, far more than words ever can. Bless you all.

 

Ratu Joni, a national treasure set aside (2016)

[The Fiji Times, 6 Oct. 2016]

Countries in political turmoil are fortunate indeed and blessed, if they have persons of stature, who have the capacity to bring opposing views or even warring factions together, who can be beacons of principle. Ratu Joni Madraiwiwi was one such person, a national treasure, whose gifts, sadly, were not taken advantage of by those in power and their advisers.

It is ironic that with his untimely passing, Ratu Joni Madraiwiwi now receives an endless series of accolades: “a great son of Fiji, a brilliant mind, a wise adviser, a meritorious high chief, a pillar of ethics, a font of humility, a committed social reformer, a defender of the weak and vulnerable, an irreplaceable loss for Fiji”, … and many more.

These accolades are fully deserved. But their delivery only after Ratu Joni has passed on, underline the harsh historical reality that those who assumed power with the 2006 military coup, including some who are praising him today, were complicit in Ratu Joni’s ejection from his high office of Vice President of Fiji, where his widely acknowledged and scarce talents were so badly needed. Many of the people who today easily praise Ratu Joni, need to ask why they did not raise their voices when this great principled man was illegally and forcibly ejected from his position as Vice President, and would Fiji have been better had they done so.

Ratu Joni could have easily compromised his principles and enjoyed great material personal benefit, as others have. But he refused to compromise, even though it led to his marginalization from high office and great personal cost.

The ongoing tragedy for Fiji’s future generations is that our society, for the last ten tumultuous years, has not held up Ratu Joni as a leader worth emulating, despite his praiseworthy principled opposition to illegality, breaches of human rights and denials of natural justice, which have sadly become the norm in the fields of civil service, law, politics, society, academia and religion. The ongoing tragedy is that the current social consciousness is being manipulated to encourage Fiji’s younger generation to emulate those who have used force to impose their wishes on Fiji people.

If Fijian parents can use the sad opportunity presented by Ratu Joni’s death to go beyond the flood of accolades and encourage their children to recognize and practice the principles that Ratu Joni passionately believed in and practiced, then his untimely demise will not have been in vain. To merely mouth the platitudes now that Ratu Joni is gone, is to perpetuate our current illusion of a just, fair and humane society, an illusion which Ratu Joni quietly struggled to dispel.

A brilliant career

Many writers will outline Ratu Joni’s brilliant career. A few of his close personal friends may reveal their privileged memories of the great man, and his personal travails even while contributing to national life, despitethechallenges. ForallknowthatRatuJoniwasnotafraidoftacklingthemanynationallysensitive political and social issues, especially those pertaining to the indigenous Fijian and other communities, which he always tried to balance with the legitimate needs of others. All know of Ratu Joni’s frequent calls for ethical and committed leadership, and good governance from all citizens in the private, corporate and public spheres.

NGOs like Citizens Constitutional Forum and Fiji Women’s Rights Movement well know his dedicated involvement with social and political organizations for reform with equality for all ethnic groups, women and children, especially after the 1987 coup and movement towards the 1997 Constitution.

There will be many accounts of his excellent performance as a High Court judge, or his untiring enlightened work as Vice President of Fiji, ever ready to use his office to launch works that he believed would bring economic, political and social progress to our society, without marginalizing the weak and vulnerable.

The corporate world well knew of his commitment to constitutionality, law and order, without which the business world of contracts would fall into chaos, with total loss of investor confidence, and suppression of economic growth and well being.

He was also a friend of the union movement and the need to protect the most vulnerable workers, such as those covered by Wages Councils.

The many accounts will praise Ratu Joni’s excellent command of law, politics, economics, religion, and society, and indeed, his command of the English language, as is evident from his book A Personal Perspective, a collection of his presentations and commentaries to various professional, political and social gatherings.

There will be many truthful accounts of his great gentleness, his warmth and humility, his unassuming nature, and his genuine multiracial character, with many multiracial friends from all walks of life .

Though Ratu Joni Madraiwiwi never dwelt on it (he always signed himself as “Joni”), he was a nephew of the great Ratu Sukuna, with all the chiefly linkages to justify appointment to high position himself, although merit alone justified his appointment.

No one will dispute that here was a man who was the ideal President of all Fiji.

So why was he removed from office?

Given the essential truth of the accolades that are being bestowed on the late Ratu Joni, all Fiji citizens must have the honesty to face up to the horrible question: why was he then removed so ignominiously as Vice President in the December 2006 military coup? Did the military’s legal advisers, among whom were some of Ratu Joni’s close personal friends, believe that Ratu Joni as Vice President would be an uncompromising obstacle to the military decrees that were to be passed, including those infringing on basic human rights, of freedom of association and assembly, freedom of the media and free speech?

Did they expect that Ratu Joni would have objected to the unilateral closing down of the Great Council of Chiefs, the discriminatory suppression of the Methodist Church (even though he opposed the idea of Fiji being a Christian State), the media censorship, the abrogation of the 1997 Constitution and the eventual imposition of the 2013 Constitution?

Almost certainly, they must have known that Ratu Joni would have refused to sign the numerous decrees that undermined basic human rights in Fiji, even as other Presidents signed them, later.

In the midst of our national mourning, Fiji should have no doubt that Ratu Joni’s nationally valuable talents were marginalized, precisely because of his passionate and uncompromising adherence to constitutionalityandtheruleoflaw. RatuJoniwasmarginalizedbecausehebelievedtotheendthatpeaceful dialogue and compromise was the only lawful, right, decent and civilized way to resolve national political differences.

But Ratu Joni’s beliefs did not suit the agenda of those who chose to use force to remove elected governments and judiciaries, to impose their own form of dictatorial government and constitution, to deny public accountability and transparency to taxpayers for eight years, and to use political propaganda, intimidation of the media, and electoral bribery to unfairly win political power.

It is ironic that some of those today bestowing praise on the late Ratu Joni, would not support the peaceful cooperative processes and politics that Ratu Joni and other likeminded people had so painstakingly built up after the 1987 and 2000 coups. It is sad that some of the good and influential people who are liberal today with their accolades of the late Ratu Joni, were silent when he was removed as Vice President.

Some might quibble that Ratu Joni, despite being the Roko Tui Bau and Vice President with all the status and powers, did not fight to defend his position: when told by the military to go, he quietly went, without public complaint. But that was the nature of the man. Sadly, there his contributions to Fiji ended.

In the last years of Ratu Joni’s life, other Pacific countries- Tonga, Solomon Islands, Nauru- recognized and took advantage of Ratu Joni’s professional talents and innate wisdom.

As was noted two thousand years ago, a prophet is rarely recognized by his own country, friends or family!

A reluctant leader

Ratu Joni was a nephew of Ratu Sir Lala Sukuna, who also groomed Ratu Sir Kamisese Mara for leadership. While Ratu Mara so successfully responded to the political challenges and was Fiji’s Prime Minister for seventeen years, Ratu Joni had no such political ambitions. It was with great reluctance that Ratu Joni even became Roko Tui Bau, not because of personal ambition, but largely because he felt deeply, the weight of social expectations,

He was often overwhelmed by the burden of social leadership, once wryly and humorously admitting to close friends that his favorite pastime was to “peacefully stare at the ceiling”. I suspect that Ratu Joni understood only too well, but without any bitterness, that social leadership of Fijians was a thankless task, often a one way street.

Like Ratu Sir Kamisese Mara before him in the coup of 2000, Ratu Joni Madraiwiwi would also have felt the deep sadness that comes to leaders who are removed from office, without protest by their followers, the same who readily mourn at the leaders’ passing.

It is easy to be cynical of the crude simplistic interpretation of the Biblical saying “Blessed are the meek fortheyshallinherittheearth”. ForRatuJoni,whomightappeartosometobeameekperson,quiteclearly never wanted to inherit the physical earth. Ratu Joni’s “meekness” was simply a reflection of his principled refusal to use his considerable powers for his own material or political self-interest, a manifestation of the deep quiet moral strength that comes to those with a full awareness of their intrinsic worth, position and value to society- which some call “wisdom”.

Ratu Joni Madraiwiwi would have been more than pleased if the accolades gracing his death leads to even a few young leaders to recognize and put into practice, the very principles and values that he deeply believed in and practiced, despite the personal cost that such commitment inevitably brings. Unfortunately, this worthy inheritance of Ratu Joni will not fall like manna from heaven- it will have to be struggled for, against the odds prevailing in Fiji today.

Adi Lusiana, Ratu Joni’s family and his extended mataqali can rightly feel proud of the contributions this wonderful gentle person has made to the vanua, to Fiji and the wider Pacific.